Put first 5 ingredients in a shaker and shake for 10 seconds.
Divide between two 14 ounce glasses filled with ice.
Garnish with a fresh shaving of nutmeg plus a lime and cherry on a plastic sword or toothpick.
Notes
* I started making my own grenadine after reading the list of ingredients on a bottle of Rose's grenadine. * For dye-free cherries try Tillen Farms’ Merry Maraschino Cherries. I find them in the natural food section at Wegmans.
Recipe by Riegl Palate at https://www.rieglpalate.com/planters-punch/